DOC Commander in Chief: FDR's Battle with Churchill; 1943 (FDR at War) by Nigel Hamilton in History

Review

87 of 91 people found the following review helpful. Easily one of the finest series of books ever written on FDRBy Robert MooreI took a little longer than I usually do to write a review for a Vine Program item because I felt I needed to read the first book in what will be; when completed; a multiple volume history of FDR as a military leader in WW II. I have to confess that I was sceptical that I would learn much from this book. FDR is; after all; one of my passions in studying presidential history. I've read the standard biographies by Geoffrey Ward (including the wonder volume of letters that FDR wrote to his cousin and perhaps closest friend Daisy Suckley); Jean Edward Smith marvelous one-volume biography; James MacGregor Burns's marvelous two-volume one; the first three volumes of Kenneth Davis's five-volume one (something I intend to get back to); Doris Kearns Goodwin's elegantly written account of the White House in the war years; and Arthur Schlesinger's huge three-volume history of the New Deal as well as William Leuchtenburg's one-volume study of the same subject. I have read the memoirs/biographies by Frances Perkins; Grace Tully; Joseph Lash; and Robert Sherwood (the latter a gargantuan joint bio of FDR and Hopkins during WW II). I've read books by two different Brinkley's; Alan's brief and lackluster book for Oxford University Press and Douglas's huge book on FDR's influence on our park system. And there have been bios or memoirs by or on people like Eleanor; Louis Howe; Arthur Schlesinger; John Kenneth Galbraith; and others; all associated with FDR's administrations; and a variety of books from the dull (Jonathan Alter's THE DEFINING MOMENT) to the fascinating (Hugh Gregory Gallagher's fascinating FDR'S SPLENDID DECEPTION; about how FDR and his team managed the public perception of him after the loss of the use of his legs due to polio - which was enhanced by a visit a year ago to Warm Springs; where a member of the staff generously escorted me and my friend around the grounds and buildings of the rehabilitation center; and later that day to the Little White House; where visitors can stand only a couple of feet from the chair in which he was sitting when he suffered a brain aneurysm and the bedroom only a few feet away where he died shortly afterwards - if you have any interest in FDR; visiting Warm Springs is a MUST). Plus FDR had popped up in book after book that I had read on any of a number of subjects; from histories of WW II to historical surveys such as Kennedy's great book in the Oxford History of the United States series; FREEDOM FROM FEAR; covering 1918-1945.In other words; I really didn't think Hamilton was going to teach me anything. Man; was I wrong! I knew the overall story and while he has as his central goal revealing precisely how gifted FDR was as a military leader; I had gleaned that many in fact did regard him very highly. In fact; both Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin; neither known for their humility; each said that FDR was the person most responsible for the allies winning WW II. Of course; that isn't quite an endorsement of him as a military leader; but it is cutting rather a fine line in saying that it doesn't to a large degree acknowledge his skills as a military leader. But Hamilton did make me aware; to a degree that I had never grasped before; the extent to which FDR "managed" his generals and admirals; fragmenting each one's authority and area of command; withholding information to each of the plans of another; so that no one could truly challenge his preeminence in handling the War. In episode after episode - and the book really is arranged in what one could call episodes or segments; in which one very precise portion of the overall narrative was dealt with in detail - Hamilton is able to show FDR's extraordinary skill in managing those under his command; without them in most cases even being aware that he was doing it. Other writers on FDR have revealed to a greater degree other aspects of FDR; such as his compassion for everyday people or his passion for a truly democratic and egalitarian society (despite being a card-carrying member of the upper crust); and others have detailed some of his faults in more detail. But Hamilton revealed something that I had never grasped before and that is FDR's genius at listening to people. Some biographers have considered it a flaw in FDR that someone would talk to him and explain passionately their position; FDR smiling and nodding his head the whole while so that they thought he was committing himself to their point of view. But Hamilton helped me understand that in reality what he was doing at such time was not misleading them; but instead listening intently.The first volume in this set is THE MANTLE OF COMMAND and does a splendid job of covering the first year of the war. This is a review of the second volume; but let me just say that Hamilton could have begun that book earlier than he did. To me; some of FDR's greatest moments came when he; seemingly alone in the US government; understood the gravity of what was happening in Europe in 1939 and 1940; namely; that the destiny of the human race was at stake; but was limited both by the constitution and by the opinion both of others in government and of the American people as to what he could do. Yet; he was able to do an amazing number of things to help Great Britain. For example; while the British were able to avert a war-ending disaster at Dunkirk; they nonetheless had to leave behind nearly all of their munitions. Had Hitler chosen to invade right at that moment; the British simply had no bullets. But in a matter of a few weeks FDR had managed to provide the British with millions of rounds of surplus WW I ammo. It wasn't the finest ammunition in the world; but the miracle was that the British got it at all. It is extraordinary how many ships; vehicles; bullets; rifles; machine guns; and airplanes FDR was able to procure for Great Britain when many in Congress; including most in the Republican party following the lead of Sen. Robert Taft; one of the nation's leading isolationists (not that there weren't many in the Democratic party of a similar frame of mind). FDR was able to do an unbelievable amount of things when on paper he should have been able to do virtually nothing.The second volume takes us into the second year of the US's involvement in the war and focuses on FDR managing the differing goals and expectations of Churchill; Stalin; and his own staff. In virtually every incident; Hamilton is able to shed new light on FDR's strategy as a leader and his goals as commander in chief. My other great presidential passion is Lincoln; and in comparing the two; FDR emerges as perhaps the most gifted of the two as a purely military leader. Of course; FDR had an advantage in having served as assistant head of the Navy in WW I (the head of the Navy was actually a figurehead; and it was FDR who did most of the work of running the ships of state (pun intended). Lincoln was a very fast learner; but he lacked confidence in the early years of the Civil War in fighting with his generals. Lincoln came to understand that he had ceded them too much control; while FDR from the outset of the war kept the reins firmly in his own hands.The first two volumes in this series are essential reading for anyone wanting to understand either FDR's role in WW II or; in fact; WW II in itself. Much is made in books on WW II or on the Nazis or on Hitler about Hitler's ineptitude in conducting the war. FDR exercised a similar degree of control on the Allied side; but luckily for us; FDR turned out to be something of a genius at least not just our nation; but all nations; in fighting the Axis powers. This completely supersedes other books on FDR's role in WW II such as Thomas Fleming's THE NEW DEALER'S WAR. I would; in fact; place this on a small list of the most crucial books for understanding the presidency of FDR.5 of 5 people found the following review helpful. Commander in Chief is the second volume in the proposed trilogy of books on FDR in World War II by Dr. Nigel HamiltonBy C. M MillsCommander in Chief is the second volume in Dr. Nigel Hamilton's proposed trilogy on President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1882-1945) and his inspired creative genius in leading the Allies to victory over the Axis Powers in World War II. In this volume the author focuses on the pivotal year of 1943. In this volume the growing rift between FDR and Winston Churchill the great wartime Prime Minister of Great Britain over Allied strategy is the main focus. It was a year notable for:a. The Casablanca Conference at which the policy of Unconditional Warfare against the Axis powers of Germany; Italy and Japan and their allies is strongly enunciated by FDR.b.The Trident Conference in Washington DC during the spring of 1943 saw Churchill argue for attacking the Nazis through Italy and the Balkans rather than engage in the cross channel invasion favored by FDR; General Marshall and American top brass. FDR won the argument insisting on the initiation of Overlord that led to the Normandy landings in June 1944.c. Stalin and the Soviets favored the Normandy landings forcing German troops into a pincer with the Western Allies advancing through France into the Reich and the Soviets moving through Eastern Europe and into Germany.d. FDR also had to manage the Pacific strategy against Japan. It was notable that Admiral Yamamoto the architect of the Pearl Harbor attack was shot down and killed in this year.e. FDR favored the establishement of a United Nations following the end of the war and was against the colonialism espoused by Churchill the old Victorian. FDR was much more democratic and forward looking in his views than was Churchill.f. The strategy of American troops participating in the invasion of North Africa; Sicily; Sardinia and up the Italian boot before launching the French invasion was a wise policy.g. FDR picked General Dwight. D. Eisenhower to lead the Overlord landings. An inspired choice of commander! Nigel Hamilton makes clear the differences in strategy between the Americans and the British. One concludes this excellent book on strategy and combat thankful that a genius like FDR was in charge of the war against the Axis Powers. An excellent volume!2 of 2 people found the following review helpful. This is a truly excellent book for anyone interested in World War 2 generallyBy Steven ToboroffThis is a truly excellent book for anyone interested in World War 2 generally; and F.D.R.'s role in it specifically. After reading volume 1 in this series (Master and Commander); which I greatly enjoyed as well; I eagerly began Commander in Chief. I was not disappointed. While I could make a few petty complaints about the author's style or structure; I will refrain based upon the overwhelming success Hamilton attains in this informative; readable; and provocative book. This book deals with the strategic decisions of Churchill; F.D.R.; Hitler; and many Generals and subordinates; while at the same time painting vivid and compelling portraits of the men who helped saved; or tried to destroy; civilization. Whether you are a lifelong student of WW2; or someone looking for a series to introduce you to the vast subject; Hamilton's series is well worth the investment in time and money. I eagerly await volume 3; and will place it on the top of my reading list as soon as it is available.